Business Loans are more difficult to obtain
than personal loans. Most cases, lenders
will not consider any business loan for a
company that has been in business less than
2 years.
New Businesses
The Small Business Administration (SBA),
often has some exceptional programs and
rates for new businesses, but most of the
time, the SBA requires a great deal of
paperwork, a large amount of money down,
very good credit, take a long
time to process, and take most or all of your
business and personal assets (such as your home)
as collateral.
Other types of small business loans.
Include lenders that will give you a loan at a
slightly than higher market rate simply based on
you having a lot of equity in your home. In such
a case, it will be easier to just use your home
and not involve yourself in all the other
complications described above. Many people who
are starting businesses don’t want to put up
their home as security. This will limit your
options. Looked at objectively, it is someone
who doesn’t want to risk their home but wants a
lender to lender to risk their capital on a new
business. Often, this outlook not always
realistic and won’t work. And surprisingly, the
SBA will often take everything your business
owns and also take your home as collateral
anyway for small business loans. As a business
owner you intend to grow your business and you
may need additional small business loans for
inventory, raw materials, expansion, relocation,
partner buyouts, etc. within the next 5 years.
If the SBA has all of your business assets and
personal assets as collateral, you will be in an
almost impossible position the next time your
business needs a loan.
Another exception of a less than 2 Year old
business getting a loan is if the business wants
a lower amount of money, say $20,000 or less and
the owner has strong personal credit. Some
institutions will make such a loan on the basis
that if you would have qualified for a personal
loan for such an amount, why would they turn you
down simply because it’s a business loan
request? They will just make you personally
guarantee it. For all intents and purposes it’s
really a personal loan set up as a business
loan.
Existing Businesses
It is
difficult to get a business loan through
traditional sources (Brick and Mortar Banks),
even if you have a relationship with them.
Traditional sources have a very high decline
rate for business loan requests and decline your
request for many more reasons than
non-traditional sources of capital. They will
request financial statements, Tax Returns, have
many questions along the way, and will greatly
scrutinize your cash flow, assets and secondary
sources of payment.
Once the bank has turned you down, all their
talk about how much they “value your
relationship”, doesn’t do you any good. What
should you do? Know what’s important in securing
a business loan.
WHAT'S IMPORTANT
The
type of business you have, how long you have
been in business, your company credit, your
personal credit, and your collateral all play a
major role in obtaining other types of capital.
Type of Business
Some lenders favor certain industries over
others. Restaurants, Food Service, Bars, Vending Companies and other retail
oriented business are not favored by
institutions. They will take your application
and will give you the same impression that you
are as likely to get a loan with them as any
other industry, but the reality is different.
Many traditional lenders in general prefer
Medical or Legal Professionals, large
manufacturing companies or non-retail service
companies.
Time in Business
In most cases,
lenders want you to be in business for two years
or more before they will even begin to consider
you for a business loan.
Some want 3 to 5 years or more in business and 2
Years of profitable tax returns. The main reason
is that a substantial number of businesses fail
within the first 5 years. Another is that if you
haven’t been in business for 2 years or more,
you won’t have the tax returns or financial
statements they need to look at your cash flow.
In addition, it takes most companies two years
or longer before they begin to show profits that
will qualify them for loans.
Business Credit
When a business applies for a loan, the
lender often will check to see if the business
has a business credit file. The company most
often used for this purpose is Dun & Bradstreet,
although there are others such as CIT and
Experian.
The primary things lenders look for in this
report is to verify the starting date of the
company, the high credit, and look for what is
known as a “Paydex” score. This score is similar
to the “bureau” score on the personal credit
file.
Approvable Paydex scores begin at around 60,
depending on other factors, such as amount of
the request, type of request, personal credit,
but most lenders like to see a Paydex Score of
70 or higher, preferably 75 or higher. The
lender will also consider the high credit
reflected on the report and see if there are any
current past dues showing. Often, the reportings
are outdated, so you should check to make sure
your listings are current and accurate before
you apply. You should first determine if you
even have a business credit file.
If you do not have a business credit file, it is
an advantage, sometimes critical for a business
to have a strong business credit file. If you do
not have a business credit file, you can
establish one, but will have to pay a few
hundred dollars for it. This is money well
spent. The Credit agency will ask you to give
them your creditor’s basic contact and account
information. They will call to verify the
information and report it on your file.
Normally, this will take up to a month. A faster
approach is for you to call your trade
references and have them call the Business
Credit Bureau(s) to report about the accounts
you have with them. This will speed things up
greatly.
The Business Credit agencies will give you a
good idea about what kind of creditors they will
list as business credit tradelines. It is
sometimes different than personal credit trade
lines.
Example:
Acme
General Contracting buys concrete periodically
from Concrete Central. The most they have ever
bought or owed at one time was $30,000. This
would be, along with timeliness of payments, the
high credit Concrete Central would report to Dun
& Bradstreet about Acme General Contracting.
Dun & Bradstreet will often even report accounts
like Federal Express type on the file. They will
mix them in by industry rather than itemizing
them. Contact Dun & Bradstreet and other
business credit agencies for details.
What
will they look at?
If you are a large company with say $10MM in
sales per year and you are seeking a $500,000
loan request, then be prepared to provide at
least several years tax returns, accountant
audited financial statements and 6 months bank
statements for the credit review process. The
more you ask for, the more that will be
requested and the more it will be scrutinized.
Personal Credit
The credit
reviewed in Business Loan requests is not
limited to Business Credit. Your personal credit
is reviewed and considered a majority of the
time.
Many people believe when they apply for small
business loans that because the request is in
the name of the business, their personal credit
won’t be or shouldn’t be looked at. No so. In
most cases, personal credit will be reviewed and
the owners(s) of the company will be asked to
individually guarantee the loan.
The reason is that most companies are small
companies and if the owner or president has a
personal credit problem, there is a good chance
it will affect the business, including checking
accounts, business loans, etc. The larger a
company is, the less likely a personal credit
problem an owner is having will affect the
company. The size of a company is usually
determined by the Annual Sales and the number of
employees.
If a company is a Sole Proprietorship or
Partnership, the personal credit of the owners
will always be reviewed, and the owners will
always be required to sign as a guarantor. This
is because the owners are not a separate legal
entity from the company. They are the company. A
corporation is legally a separate entity from
the owners. The owners own stock in the
corporation, but it can be a small percentage of
the stock.
Generally, the only time the personal credit of
an owner may not be reviewed and the owner not
asked to be a signer on the loan is for
corporations that have been incorporated for 3
years or longer with strong business credit.
Otherwise, your personal credit will be reviewed
as part of the decision.
Collateral
The type of
collateral you have to offer when applying for
small business loans is an important factor in
determining if you will be approved.
You must qualify from a credit and cash flow
standpoint before your collateral is considered.
When you are at that point, the collateral can
be a make or break issue.
Liquid Collateral such as Certificates of
Deposit, Corporate Savings Accounts, Money
Market Accounts are most preferred, especially
by banks.
When banks suggest or ask for this type of
collateral, many applicants state that if they
had the amount of their request in cash, they
wouldn’t need a business loan. This is true, but
many businesses recognize that it can be
dangerous for them to use most or all of their
existing cash because if something comes up for
which their business needs cash fast, their
company can run into a problem. This is why some
companies apply for loans even if they have the
cash on hand. Very large companies commonly do
this and use their cash on hand as needed for
other things.
Some Banks are so conservative, they may decline
your request even if you have a Certificate of
Deposit in cash for the amount of your request.
Their reasoning is that they want a high comfort
level that you will pay the loan back from your
cash flow. They do not want to have to cash in
your collateral to repay the loan, so they don’t
want to make small business loans to companies
they feel will have trouble making the payments
solely because the company has a certificate of
deposit to cover the loan.
The owner of a company has the option of taking
personal cash funds, converting them into a
Business Certificate of Deposit, Business
Savings Account, Business Money Market Account
or Listed Stock, put it in the Business name and
use it as collateral.
Real Estate, especially personal Real Estate
such as a home with a lot of equity is one of
the most favored types of collateral. Other than
a Certificate of Deposit or Savings Account
being held as collateral, lenders feel that they
will most easily be able to recover their money
in the event of a default with a home. A lender
can sell a home more quickly and recover a
greater percentage of the loan than with a
commercial piece of property or other types of
assets.
Lenders will take commercial pieces of property
as collateral, but want to see more equity in
commercial property than in personal property
such as homes. Lenders know that it will take
them longer to sell commercial property and they
will have to offer a much greater discount from
the appraised value if they want to sell it
fast, which they need to do to recover their
money in the event of a default.
Accounts Receivable will be valued as collateral
depending on the quality of the companies that
owe the money, the time on the receivables, and
how many companies account for the total
Accounts Receivable. The pay history of these
accounts will also be looked at. How
aggressively the company works to collect the
accounts receivable on a timely basis is
considered.
Equipment is not considered a primary or
significant type of collateral by lenders.
Equipment loses it value fairly rapidly and in
the event of a default, if the lender decides to
reposes the collateral, the lender will have to
arrange for it to be picked up. It will often be
sold by a third party vendor in the secondary
market. The lender will recover a fraction of
the outstanding loan and take a significant
loss. For this reason, most lenders will over
collateralize loans with equipment as by a
significant margin, often 200% to 1000% of the
current value.
Blanket Liens are liens that cover all business
assets you own. Lenders will often try to take
everything your business owns including personal
assets such as your home as collateral for small
business loans. As a business owner you intend
to grow your business and you may need
additional small business loans for things such
as marketing expenses, expansion, raw materials,
raw materials, relocation, etc. within the next
5 years. If the lender has all of your business
assets and personal assets as collateral, you
will be in a very difficult position the next
time your business needs a loan.
STRATEGY
Your company
needs $100,000. Most companies will go to one
place and ask for $100,000. This is not always
the best approach. . What if you would have
qualified for $70,000 but not for $100,000? Tell
the lender up front what you want, but if they
cannot give that to you, what amount can they
do, and under what conditions?
If the first lender can approve you, depending
on what they want for collateral, it is wise to
try to negotiate the collateral. If your company
has $2MM worth of equipment, $1MM in Accounts
receivable, Real Estate worth $2MM, and you are
asking for $200,000, some institutions may try
to take everything you own as collateral. This
is when you should try to negotiate what they
take as collateral.
Suggest up front what you want to offer as
collateral. Simply put, if you give it to them,
they will take it. You may end up having to
provide all this collateral and institutions
normally don’t negotiate this, but most people
don’t try to negotiate this. They think if the
bank asks for it, it is set in stone.
An example would be for you to negotiate and the
lender agrees to take everything but the
Accounts Receivable and equipment as collateral,
or maybe the Equipment and Accounts Receivable
but not the land. Lenders are not used to the
borrower handling it this way, but you wont’ get
it if you don’t ask for it.
Another major reason to do this is that
traditional lenders will automatically take most
everything you have as collateral. Suppose you
are requesting a 6 year loan. If the bank takes
all your assets as collateral, now have no
collateral to offer should you need to borrow
again in the next 6 years. Does the lender care
about that? No, but you need to put great
importance on that.
As the owner of the business, you intend to
expand in the next several years. It is just as
likely that due to expansion, need for
inventory, raw materials, relocation, marketing
programs, etc. that you will need capital again
before the current loan is paid off. When that
happens, all your assets will still be tied up
in the original loan. You certainly won’t be
able to get a totally unsecured loan at that
time. Don’t count on previous lender to release
part of your collateral just because you balance
is a small fraction of the original amount. They
rarely do.
If this does not work, another approach could be
to get either the same amount of loan, but half
from one lender and the other half from another
lender. Or to get different types of small
business loans from different lenders. All
things equal at your company, it will be harder
for you to get $150,000 from one lender than it
will be to get $75,000 from two lenders. You
could use the Accounts Receivable for one loan
and the equipment for another. That could leave
the land free for a future request.
Watch out!
Buying A Business
If you want to buy an existing business,
financing can be difficult to obtain. You will
be looked at as a new owner. There are options
that make it easier to arrange this type of
financing…….more
Asking the owner to Self Finance part of the
sale is a creative option that many people
overlook or don’t negotiate aggressively enough.
Most people cannot get a small business loan to
100% cover the purchase, so ask the owner to
finance a percentage of the purchase to you
directly.
Being able to sell the business is the
motivation the seller has to self finance a part
of the business to you. The higher the
percentage you ask the seller to finance
themselves, the more motivation you need to give
them to do so. Should you not make your payments
on time, you can arrange for certain increasing
penalties, the more delinquent the payments
become. If you are more than 60 days Past due on
your payments, you can increase the late fees.
You can put in a clause that in event of a
default, certain assets automatically become
property of the seller.
Buyers typically do not want to arrange this
type of financing, but if it is your goal to
have that business, you must be willing to take
aggressive risks in order to give the seller a
compelling reason to accept less than 100% of
what the business is worth.
Call Options
Some loans
will have covenants or provisions that seem
minor but can really cause problems later.
Traditional lenders like to put clauses into
their loans that allow them to “Call” the loan
anytime.
This means that if they feel like it, they can
call you anytime and demand you payoff the
balance either immediately or within 30 days!
This can be devastating to your business. Try to
negotiate that out of your loan. Any one of a
number of things could happen that are out of
your control and the bank might call the loan.
The economy could worsen. Maybe you were paying
a little slow on your loan, and they had an
upsurge in defaulted loans and they decided to
call all but the best paying loans. It could be
they urgently needed capital and to help
themselves they call the loan. These things
could happen! What would you do?
If you try to get it re-financed at another
bank, the other bank will soon figure out that
your bank is calling the loan, which they
consider a negative, justified or not.
If you cannot get it re-financed, you are now
wide open to that bank suing you, reposing your
assets, selling them and then you are out of
business. Avoid a call option being put in your
loan.
Annual Payouts
Some lenders
that approve you for a business line of credit
will have a condition in the line of credit for
you to pay the balance down to $0 once per year,
regardless of how much you borrow, how well you
pay.
This could be extremely difficult for you to do.
If you fail to do so, the remaining conditions
for failure to annually pay out could be severe.
Depending on the loan contract, they may have
the option to do any number of things from
raising the rate to calling the loan.
Company Only or Corp only Loans
Some lenders
will approve loans that are just in the name of
the company, that is, no principal or signer is
required to guarantee the loan. This only occurs
with Corporations, and is most often considered
for 5 Year or older corporations.
The idea behind these began with larger
companies.
For example, if Coca-Cola takes out a $500
Million loan, none of the employees or officers
of the company would consider individually
guarantee these, otherwise the lender could come
after them if the loan is in default and ruin
them financially.
In such a loan, the loan is in the name of the
company only, so if the company defaults, the
lender can only liquidate the company assets in
their efforts to partially repay the balance of
the loan.
An Example of this was Eastern Air Lines. The
lender actually sold the hard assets of the
company to repay the loan as much as possible.
This is another reason to incorporate and work
to establish business credit. Within a few
years, you will then be considered for some
types of small business loans and other types of
capital in the company name only without having
to individually guaranteeing every loan.
Another benefit is that any small business loans
you do not guarantee will not show up on your
personal credit report. If you are having to
currently guarantee all business loans now, it
is likely these loans are showing up on your
personal credit report. This will cause you to
to appear to be overextended when in fact the
revenues from your business is being used to pay
these loans rather than from your personal
income. The more of these you personally
guarantee, the harder it will be to get other
personal loans or small business loans in the
future since you appear to be making yourself
more and more “debt heavy”, based on your
personal credit bureau.
|