|
When you
apply for most personal loans, the main
factors taken into account are not just
credit, but other major factors are income,
length & type of employment & amount
requested. Each institution you apply with
will….. has the right to assign different
levels of importance to any of these, or any
other characteristics, but most companies
look at these factors. Generally, you will
be applying at Non Government Institutions.
Since these are private institutions, other
than basic factors like race, religion, sex,
etc, each company can and will set their own
guidelines.
There are 3 major credit reporting agencies in
the US, Equifax, Experian, & Transunion.
When you apply for a consumer or even a business
loan, the consumer bureau that is used will
often be based on what region of the country you
live in. If you live in the Eastern &
Southeastern United States, Equifax will often
be used, Experian for the Midsouth and West, and
Transunion for the Midwest. Although all are
full national bureaus, each bureau tends to be
strongest in those regions and will have the
most complete file.
All three bureaus are not mirrors of one
another. There may be both good or bad
tradelines in one or two bureaus, that are not
reported in the others. Some companies that you
are applying with will use what’s called a
“Tri-Merge”. In a Tri-Merge report, the company
you have applied with will see a combined file
so that every trade line will be seen. They will
also see the credit score you received on each
bureau. If one of the scores at one bureau is
considerably lower than the score at the other
two bureaus, this may influence their decision.
The credit score,
which may also be called “Fico Score”, or
“Beacon Score”, or “Empirica Score” is a risk
score assigned to you. Many companies consider a
number of primary and secondary factors about
your bureau to determine if your risk level is
acceptable.
for their
standards, but the bureau score is the single
most important factor.
Since most companies you apply at will be
private institutions, it is at their discretion
who will be approved for a loan. What Company A
decides is acceptable may not be acceptable to
company B. Other important bureau factors
include Time in File, high credit, number of
Tradelines, number of recent inquiries, total
credit card balances, unsecured account balances
as a percentage of limits, and derogatory
reportings. All of these affect that final
credit bureau score.
If you have been approved, great! If you were
declined, get a copy of your credit report to
see what is on the report. The credit report you
receive will probably have a different format
than the ones used by companies you have applied
at. It will be less technical, will rely more on
words than on numbers, and may not have a credit
score.
Many large companies will “Auto Decision” your
application, meaning a computer will decide if
you get the loan or not. Another technique is
for the computer to auto decline the
applications that are below an absolute low
standard and auto approve those with score and
characteristics so high that the institution is
comfortable granting credit without a person
even looking at your application. This means you
may be declined by a computer. The applications
in between are often sent to a credit person for
review.
In many smaller companies, an individual will
review every request. Statistics prove that over
time, as far as the overall default rate, better
decisions are made by the computer risk models.
These computer risk models are developed
in-house by some large companies, or purchased
from outside vendors. Tens of thousands of real
applications and their performance over a period
of years are assessed in order to create these
computer credit risk models and to assign risk
levels and scores. They are applied to new
applications since prior performance is the best
indicator of future performance.
However, mistakes are made.
Example:
When
a credit card issuer sets a cap on the amount of
unsecured revolving credit they are willing to
have any one applicant have (Credit Cards, Lines
of Credit). If an applicant is above that
threshold, they will be declined. On credit
reports, credit cards and lines of credit will
be listed on an account as an “R”, for
revolving. Many homeowners have an equity line
of credit with a high limit which unfortunately,
the credit agencies may report as an “R” and
incorrectly lump these lines together with
credit cards and lines of credit when reporting
your total unsecured credit. This error may also
be caused by a companies risk evaluation models.
This may cause you to incorrectly exceed their
maximum and be declined. The credit bureaus may
also list this as unsecured credit available,
which may slightly lower your score more than if
they had correctly listed it as a secured line.
Example:
John
Smith has 5 Credit Card for limits for $ 25,000
John also has a home equity line for $50,000
These two are lumped together and now you are
shown as having $75,000 in unsecured credit,
which some credit grantors may consider too
much.
CREDIT INQUIRIES
Each time your credit file is inquired on, your
credit score drops a few points for a relatively
short amount of time. If you
have too many inquires in too short of a time,
it can dramatically.
lower your short term credit score. If you
have 5 or more inquiries in a 30 day span, it
begins to significantly impact your score. Go
ahead and apply for what you need. The key is
to simply be aware of this, and to avoid
applying recklessly rather than to avoid
applying altogether.
Cable hookups,
department stores, automobile shopping,
apartments, all count as inquiries and can lower
your score. Most Banks will also now check your
credit when you open a new account.
Many, but not
all companies have begun to screen auto dealer
and mortgage inquires out of what they consider
inquiries since they know you are shopping for a
deal rather than trying to debt pyramid.
Time in File
The date your
first “loan” of any kind, including any type of
credit card was established. The older this
date is the better and will lower the affect
current derogatories will have on.
your credit score. The more accounts you have
that you have never been late on, and the longer
you have had them will mean that if you have a
30 day late, it will not affect your score
nearly as much as if your time in file is
short. A 30 day late will lower the score of
an average 25 year old much more than it will
lower the score of the average 45 year old.
In essence, you
have built up a “store” of good credit. It is
imperative if you are young, not to allow
anything to show up as late on your credit.
It will only make it that much harder for you
down the road. A longer time in file will
also lower the affect that charge offs, and
unpaid accounts will have. Instead of having
catastrophic affects on your credit score, it
will be significant.
High Credit
The higher this figure is in your credit file,
the more likely it will be for you to get
approved for a loan request.
Example: If
you are applying for a $20,000 credit card, even
with good credit, good income and a credit score
of over 700, if your credit file’s highest
credit card has a $2,000 limit, it is doubtful
you will be approved for a $20,0000 limit simply
because you do not have comparable credit. The
lender will feel that you have show excellent
responsibility with $2,000, but you have not
shown that you will satisfactorily handle a much
larger loan. If you took out a car loan that
had a much higher balance, it will help, but the
lender may still look to see what is the highest
credit card limit you have and make their
decision about the limit based primarily on
that.
Number of
Tradelines
The number of
Tradelines you have can have either a positive
or negative affect on your credit bureau.
A
trade line is any type of loan, credit card,
line of credit or mortgage that shows up on your
credit file. The more of these that you have
always paid on time on, in general, the stronger
your credit file is and the higher your credit
score will be.
Exceptions to
this are:
Ř
If
you have significant balances on many accounts
Ř
If
you have many credit cards, even without
balances on all. This will drive up your total
unsecured credit available, which the credit
bureaus consider in determining your credit
score.
Ř
If you have opened up a high number of accounts
in the most recent 60 days, a potential lender
reviewing your credit report may be alarmed at
the number of new accounts you have opened and
will be worried that you haven’t had enough time
to show how you will be able to handle the new
accounts. You will be considered a higher
risk.
JOINT DEBTS
If you are
married and most of your debts are joint and
your spouse has an income, you should strongly
consider submitting a joint application. Otherwise you are trying to get a credit
approval based on your total debt but less than
your total income.
If you could easily cover all your household
debts yourself and have money left over at the
end of the month, you probably can apply on your
own. If you need your spouse’s income to cover
your monthly debts, you likely need to submit a
joint application.
Debt to Income Ratio
Many lenders will use the information you
provided on your application about your income
and the information on your credit file to
calculate a Debt to Income Ratio.
Those that do take what appear to be your fixed
monthly payments (Mortgage, car, minimum
payments on loans, etc., and divide it by your
monthly income. If the ratio exceeds a certain
percent, some institutions may decline you. If
you have more than one household income, you
should strongly consider making a joint
application since you don’t want the lender to
consider your request based solely on your
income but all of your household debts.
Credit Card Balances, Limits, Usage & how to
keep your scores high
Many people
think you have to carry balances on credit cards
and loans in order for it to be considered as
“having credit”. Not so. You simply need to keep
it active. The best scenario is to have one or two high
limits on a couple of credit card accounts to
show potential future creditors that other
people have deemed you “worthy” of that amount,
but not to run them up too much & make the
lenders think you need credit badly. Ideally use
each credit card you have at least once every
month, charging any amount and then pay it off
so the account will report the current month to
the credit bureau which shows the account active
rather than dormant. This tells people you use
it but don’t need it.
If you carry balances, creditors and credit
agencies have risk “triggers” for which they
will classify you as a higher risk and
dramatically lower your credit score and
increase your possibility of being declined for
personal loans and small business loans. If you
carry balances 20%, 50% & 75% or higher of your
total limits, these are threshold limits for
many companies. The percentages and how they are
interpreted will vary slightly, but what’s
important is that overall, these are considered
elevated risk levels. A person with a $2,000
credit card and a $1,900 balance will be
penalized more in the usage category than a
person with $50,000 in limits and $30,000 in
balances.
The person with $30,000 in balances may get hit
for having a higher total, but they will get an
advantage in percentage of limit usage.
If you have 75% or higher usage and are about to
apply for an important loan, one short term
trick to improve your score is to, believe it or
not, get another credit card so that your
percent usage goes down. This is feasible and
works better in the $5K to $25K range. Someone
with $10,000 in limits and a $5,000 balance is
going to have a lower usage percentage and look
better than a person with $5,000 in limits and
$5,000 in balances, even though they owe the
same amount.
A better solution would be to simply make a
large payment on a card, even if it from a
savings account. After you get the loan, you can
“repay” your savings account if it was on a
credit card or line of credit. This will not
work with a regular installment loan.
Disputes
Many people
will at some point have a dispute with a lender,
creditor, or retailer regarding a loan or
purchase they made and will consider not paying
amounts owed because they feel they were not
given what was promised. Not paying will
probably hurt you more than it will help you.
It’s happened to most of us. We bought something
that didn’t work right, we were charged
something we felt we shouldn’t have to pay and
so we don’t. Even though we are right, it will
very likely help us more by paying rather than
not paying.
If you have a dispute and you don’t pay the
disputed amount, the other party may report this
item as unpaid on your credit report. In many
cases, disputes are less than $500. If you think
you will probably take out large loans in the
future such as a mortgage loan, car loan, or
business loan, you will likely be saving money,
be more likely to get approved, and make your
life easier by paying the disputed item.
Example:
Britney Borrower receives a bill from a recent
hospital visit and there is a charge of $300 for
an additional X-Ray she didn’t realize was
considered an additional X-Ray, wasn’t told
about it, and so Britney refuses to pay. After
120 days trying to collect from Britney, the
Hospital charges off the account and reports it
to the credit bureaus as a charge off. The
charge off reports on Britney’s credit file
beginning in July. As a result, Britney’s credit
score drops from 655 to 605.
In August Britney decides it is time to buy a
home. She goes to her bank who promptly declines
her for a loan. She finds out she is declined by
her bank due to “derogatory credit” and because
her credit score is too low (The lender’s cutoff
is 630)
Britney then goes to an alternative lender who
approves her for her $200,000 mortgage, but due
to her recent derogatory credit and low credit
bureau score, is setting her rate at 8% instead
of the 6% on a 30 year note she would have
gotten with a 655 bureau score. If Britney pays
off the entire loan, she will pay $80,000 more
in interest over the 30 years because of the
$300 X-Ray bill she didn’t pay. Britney didn’t
save $300, Britney spent $79,700 more. Of course
she was in the right, but being in the right
doesn’t always put you in the best position.
Britney’s score may go up and she may refinance,
but that will take time, and interest rates may
go up in the meantime, when she could have
locked in at a low rate.
There are many other examples, but it is
generally better to pay a disputed bill because
it will cost you more in interest on higher rate
loans than the amount in dispute.
APPROVED OR DECLINED
So you have
applied and you get a response. When you apply
for any loan, be sure to thoroughly complete the
application. Some companies, in addition to
reviewing your credit, will assign you an
internal application score.
You get this score by getting, or losing
“points” based on information you listed on your
application. If you are asked for a bank
reference but didn’t bring that information with
you, get that information, then submit your
application. Do not submit with missing
information. You may very well lose “points”
which could be the difference between an
approval and a decline.
Let’s say you are well off and you have a Money
Market Account, Certificate of Deposit, or even
an IRA with a good balance, ask a Loan Officer
if providing that information will help the
application. Sometimes it will. Basically,
companies are trying to see if you have not only
the willingness to repay based on your report,
but the capacity to repay based on your assets.
Capacity is assessed by your cash flow, back up
cash and assets. If you can show that you have a
large back up, some companies will consider
this. Willingness to repay is mostly determined
by your credit bureau. Any slow pays may have
been out of your control, but they will be taken
as is.
Additional Information
Once you have
applied, if you are contacted for additional
information, supply as much requested as
possible.
You may not have supplied enough information and
your application may be at a standstill until
this is provided. Sometimes, your application is
“declined as is” but it is a borderline case and
the loan officer wants to get something from you
to strengthen your application, which may make
an approval out of it.
Approved.
You have been
approved. If you wanted more than what you got,
ask for more. Very often, the amount you
received is not the maximum and sometimes, you
can get a 10% to 15% increase without another
credit review automatically, just by asking!
Individual Guarantee Most Loans require what is
often referred to as an individual Guarantor or
signer. Sometimes the institution says that you
are required to “sign on it”. This means more
than you are just signing to acknowledge or
agree to the terms. It means that you are
legally agreeing to personally guarantee the
loan, which gives the institution the right to
sue you for payment in the event you cannot pay.
This could include their ability to garnish your
wages, place liens on your home, etc. What the
company can do will vary from contract to
contract, but it gives them great power over
you. Most of the time you have no choice but to
sign, otherwise the loan would not have been
approved. You should simply be aware of this and
be prepared that severe negative consequences to
you are real and can easily take place if you
default or are severely delinquent.
Co-Signers
If you are
co-signing to “help” someone else get a loan,
you are just as responsible for that loan as the
person you are helping get the loan for. Many
people get derogatory items reporting on their
credit report on loans they co-signed on
because.
After they co-signed on the loan, they
considered themselves to be done with the
transaction and they forget about it. They also
don’t keep track of how the person they
co-signed for is paying on the loan. Most
companies don’t send the co-signer notices of
when the payments are due or notices that the
payments are late. It isn’t until the loan is
severely delinquent or in default status that
the co-signer is contacted for payment. By then
it has negatively affected your credit in a
major way and it is too late.
If you co-sign any personal loans or business
loans for anyone, make sure you feel they will
really repay. Keep track of the loan and have
the lender send you notices of payments due and
immediately notify you or contact you if the
payments are delinquent. Most importantly, be
prepared, as you promised with your signature,
to pay in the event the primary borrower
doesn’t.
DECLINED
You have been
declined for a personal loan request . There are
several strategies you can take.
Credit Decline
If you were
declined based on your credit report you should
immediately get a copy of your credit report.
After you receive the report.
Determine what is it that’s derogatory on your
report. Is it accurate? If so, there really
isn’t much you can do about it on the credit
report. Then all the lender who declined you.
Ask the following:
-
Were
you Auto Declined by their computer or did an
actual person review the application?
-
If
you were declined by a computer or even by an
actual person, find out who has the authority to
re-review and approve the application. Tell them
you want it to be re-reviewed by that person and
you want to speak to them. If they are
unavailable, get the name and phone number of
the person who has the authority to re-consider
it and approve it and leave a message for them
to call you back.
It
is very possible, depending on the size of the
company and what you have applied for that you
may be told that you have to wait 6 months to be
re-evaluated or that it is against their policy
and cannot be re-evaluated. In almost all cases,
if not all, the company can re-review your
application if they want to. If you are told
something like this, it is only a first line
employee telling you guideline procedures. There
will almost always be someone who has the power
to re-evaluate your application and that’s what
you want them to do. Don’t think you are being
too pushy, you can be sure there are others
doing this very thing.
Once you speak with that person, don’t complain,
give them information that they feel they could
use to justify approving the application. Most
of the time, they want to try to approve you if
they can. Then ask them what it would take for
your application to be approved. If they reverse
the decision, great, if not, follow their advice
on what it would take to get approved or put you
in the best position to get your loan request
approved.
Was there one specific thing that was
predominant in the decline? How close were to
you an approval? Find out these details. You
need to know where you stand so you’ll know what
to do to get approved next time.
What do you do now? You still need that loan.
Now you know exactly what your credit looks
like. Find another viable lender. But don’t just
start filling out loan application. Do the
following:
Call them, ask to speak with a credit officer.
Tell them what you type of loan you want, the
amount, etc..
Ask them what factors they look at in
decisioning those loans. Then tell them your
income, what your credit bureau score is and
roughly what your monthly totals are for fixed
debt or anything else that would play a major
role in approving that loan.
Try to get them to tell you if they think you
have a good chance of getting approved. They may
be reluctant to do this, but if you push an
actual loan officer, they will probably give you
a good idea. You are in essence, trying to use
what you now know about your credit to do a
verbal before you actually apply. This is
important. You have already been declined once,
you don’t want to be unnecessarily be turned
down for the same thing again or any other
reasons that you can avoid by talking with the
lenders first, if possible.
If you are dealing with a credit card issuer,
the way to handle this is to call the customer
service number and ask to speak with a
supervisor.
Credit Doctors / Bureau Cleaning Services
Some people have
tried in recent years to get Credit Doctors to
clean up their credit. This has certain
Drawbacks associated with it.
Most of these companies rely on existing rules
to help you clean up your credit. If one of your
creditors reports a derogatory item on your
credit report, there are rules to the effect
that if you contact the credit agency and
dispute that reporting, the credit agencies have
a limited number of days to contact that
creditor and ask for a verification of that
reporting. If that company fails to reply on
time, the credit bureau may have no choice but
to delete that derogatory record from your file.
These credit doctors will bombard the credit
bureaus with a volume of these request which the
credit agencies and the companies reporting you
delinquent cannot keep up and the credit
agencies will be forced to remove the derogatory
reporting from your file. Sometimes these
derogatories will re-appear on your credit file
again later and in other cases some will not
come off because the contact information for
that creditor is no longer valid. So if you have
a lot of things wrong on your file, this may not
work.
Chances are, it will not work for all of the
tradelines reporting and it will remove most of
them but not all of them. When it comes to your
credit report, even one or two very derogatory
reportings will do most of the damage to your
credit score.
Divorce
In a divorce, both parties separate debts and
believe they are not responsible for any
previous joint debts they have not agreed to
pay. This will often result in credit
problems….more
Any joint loans, be they personal loans or
business loans that a couple entered into with a
lender while they were married will continue to
be joint debts after the couple divorces
regardless of what the husband, wife, attorneys
or court orders.
When the couple entered into a joint loan with
the lender, the lender approved that loan based
on the information of both the husband and wife.
Their contract, as agreed upon by the couple, is
with the husband and wife together. If there is
a divorce, the couple cannot just split up the
debts as they see fit or have an attorney or
even the judge of a divorce court decide how the
loans will be split up.
The lenders have to agree to any separation of
debt and they have every right to refuse to. The
contact was between you, your spouse and that
company, not anyone else. It is a legally
binding contract, therefore, 3rd parties have no
legal authority to alter it afterwards. For the
lender to convert any existing debt from joint
to individual is a completely new credit
decision. They may decide that the income of one
of the parties is not enough to support the debt
that was approved jointly before, or there may
be many other legitimate reasons that the lender
felt strongly enough to make the loan together,
but would not have made the loan if one of the
people had applied individually.
Contact the lender directly and find out what
their policies are for a divorce situation. If
they tell you you must re-apply, do so. If they
will not approve you, you can take another loan
out elsewhere and pay out the existing loan and
close the account.
If you end up leaving it joint but your spouse
agrees they will pay it themselves, keep track
of the debt to make sure your spouse is paying
on time. Get the institution to send a copy to
your address if possible. If your name is on the
account, it will damage your standing with that
company if the account goes past due, and it
will damage your credit if the account goes 30
days Past Due
New Social Security Numbers
Some people who
have had major credit problems have gotten a new
social security number being told this will be a
“clean slate” wrong move.
This is only part of the story. It’s the rest
that could be your nightmare. When you are
issued “a new” Social Security Number from a
company, it could be that SSN has been stolen
from the Social Security Administration, meaning
it is a number that they intended to give to
someone else in the future. That might work in
the short term, but if the Social Security
Administration finds out, you may be contacted.
It will not be a pleasant or short experience.
Even though you have gotten a “new” SSN, once
you apply for personal loans or small business
loans, your old SSN will almost certainly ALSO
pop up as another SSN. This is a major red flag
to lenders. They realize there are a variety of
explanations for this, none of which are good.
They will think either:
1) You are a fraudulent applicant and decline
you
2) You have stolen a social security number and
are trying to start a new identity.
3) They will probably not think you have a son
or daughter with the same name as you (The best
scenario) Since this “new” SSN will have a more
recent issue date than your true one, it may not
be old enough to obtain credit. If it is, your
true SSN issue date better be at least 15 years
older than the issue date of your adopted SSN.
In all likelihood, this will not work even in
the best of circumstances. You will create more
problems than you have solved. Do not do this.
DIFFERENT TYPES OF PERSONAL LOANS
Major Financial
Institutions often do not have 1 single credit
criteria for customers for car loans, personal
loans, unsecured loans, or small business loans
throughout the bank. They may have different
credit criteria for the Branches, Credit Card
Divisions, Automotive Sales Finance Division and
Mortgage Division, even though it is the same
Institutions. Thought things would be the same
at bare minimum at the same company? Not so by a
long shot.
Car Loans
Car Loans are currently about the easiest
type of loan to be approved for. Programs for
car loans are the most aggressive credit wise
and among the most aggressively marketed due to
the affiliation of auto manufacturers, auto
dealers, and financial institutions.
If you are trying to get a car loan from a major
bank at one of their branch offices, it can be
more difficult to get approved, take longer, and
the rate may even be higher. At a Branch, either
a loan officer makes the decision or a central
area for the Branches makes the decision.
Most banks also have an additional and separate
Sales Finance Division of the, whose entire
purpose it is to also make car loans. These
Sales Finance Divisions are set up mostly to
establish and promote a business relationship
with many Car dealerships throughout the country
which the branches don’t do. Due to the intense
competition at dealerships, there is intense
pressure to get people approved to make the
sale. Each Dealership sales agent has dozens of
financial institutions they can send a car loan
request to, including the finance Divisions of
the car manufacturers themselves, with whom it
is easier to get approved and they often have
better rates. Banks know this, so they have to
match the credit standards and rates and endup
offering lower rates than what the local branch
of the same bank is offering.
The result is that the credit criteria of the
Sales Finance Division at a bank is easier to
get approved from and the rates are often better
than the rates of a branch office at the same
bank!
Many banks don’t like to re-finance car loans on
1 or 2 year old cars for the amount that will be
required to pay off the loan where you have your
car loan with now & they also don’t like to
re-finance for as many months as you had
remaining with the other company. Basically,
they don’t like to “swap out” the loan.
Therefore, make sure you are satisfied with the
rate when you take out a car loan and don’t plan
on re-financing your car loan.
In the first part of the loan, the car
depreciates the fastest and the loan balance
goes down the slowest since most of the payment
is interest. So after 1 or 2 years when you go
to refinance, a car that you bought and financed
for $20,000 now only has a book for $15,000 but
your loan balance may still be$18,500. Finance
companies call that “upside down”. They don’t
want to finance something for $18,500 that now
only has a retail value of $15,000. They may
want you to come up with $3,500 in order to
re-finance because they aren’t likely to make
you an $18,500 loan on a car with a retail of
$15,000. They also know that even if they
finance your car loan at the current retail
value, if you default, they will send the car to
auction and only get around 50% of whatever you
still owe on it. They know they are going to
lose no matter what if you default, so they
don’t want to risk more by financing you over
the retail value.
A sharp person will point out that after 1 or 2
years, lenders are “upside down” on every new
car loan they’ve made. Meaning, had they
financed you to begin with instead of another
bank, that same car loan with a loan balance of
$18,500 and a car retail value of $15,000 would
have started off on their books instead of at
another bank. So what’s the difference? Nothing,
but they don’t see that opportunity. All they
see is that you want to re-finance a loan they
will have to finance for more than 100% of the
car’s value to pay it out and they don’t like to
do it.
Once you have made a decision to go to your
Bank’s branch office for a car loan, the Loan
Officer is not showing you competitive or lower
rates offered by GMAC, Ford Motor Credit, etc,
like the Salesman at the Dealership is to his
customers. So the banks process your loan with a
higher rate and tighter credit standards. This
part of the bank is known at the “Retail” part
of the bank and it often has different criteria
for personal loans and small business loans than
other parts of the bank.
Unsecured Loans
These are
among the most difficult to get. Better credit
is required. Often, your personal credit score
needs to be 680 or higher, and the higher the
better. The Bank may have different criteria for
Unsecured loans in different divisions within
the bank. The amount you will get approved for
depends greatly on your income.
Some institutions will ask you to complete a
Personal Financial Statement if you want to get
a higher limit, often over $10K. They will take
a look at your Liquidity (How much cash type of
assets you have) and Net Worth. They may take a
percentage of each and use that as a guide to
set the limit you get. Some institutions may
take a different approach, but if they are
looking at a Personal Financial Statement, it
will be similar.
Let’s look at an example:
John Smith is approved from
his local branch of Bank U.S.A. For an
unsecured line of credit for $5,000. It is not
enough and John asks for an increase, but is
denied because, he is told, they have approved
him for the max.
A week later, a representative from Bank USA’s
Credit Card Division out of Florida calls him
and tells him he is pre-approved for a credit
card up to $12,000. He applies, and is
approved for $10,000.
This happens all the time. It
is the same bank and both are unsecured credit.
The Bank now is at risk with Joe for $15,000
total unsecured credit exposure. It should not
make any difference which part of the bank gave
Joe the credit. After all, if Joe runs in to
hard times and can’t pay, it’s the same bank
that suffers overall. That is true but the bank
doesn’t handle it that way for several reasons
The division that decides on unsecured personal
lines of credit is a different division than the
credit card division, which is a different
division than the Sales Finance Car Loan
Division. Each has different credit criteria. If
the unsecured line of credit division grants you
$5,000 Maximum and then the Credit Card Division
grants you $10,000, the credit card division
will NOT say “Oops, we see you have reached the
total maximum unsecured credit with our
institution, so we can’t give you a credit
card”. They don’t care that you already have
unsecured credit with another part of the bank.
In contrast, the unsecured division will not say
“because the credit card division is willing to
give you $10,000 unsecured, you can choose to
just increase your line with us to $15,000”.
They won’t. Each department has a different
threshold per person. They often act like
separate horses with blinders on. Each considers
themselves a Business Unit within the bank. Each
has different Presidents, different goals,
different credit criteria, different marketing
plans.
Second Mortgages
Second
Mortgages are very desirable types of loans to
get. You will get a tax advantage and most
companies prefer these types of loans above all
others.
Most lenders would much rather do a Mortgage
Loan or Second Mortgage over a personal loan,
unsecured loan or small business loan. The
reason is that your home is one of the best
types of collateral there is. They would rather
take a Certificate of Deposit for an equal
dollar amount of the loan, but many more people
have homes they can use as collateral.
You will need to know how high of a LTV (Loan to
Value) the lender will do. The higher the LTV,
the better. If a lender says they will do 90%
LTV, the following is an example:
Sally Smith has a home worth $100,000 and she
owes $50,000 on it. If the bank will loan 90%
LTV that means that she has $100,000 X .9 minus
$50,000 equity in her home. In this case,
$90,000 minus $50,000. This particular lender
will provide Sally with a maximum $40,000 equity
loan against her home.
If your credit is very strong, some lenders will
do a 100% LTV or even higher. If you have over a
725 credit score, you may be able to obtain the
maximum LTV Mortgage or Second Mortgage loan on
the market.
SELF EMPLOYED
Many Self Employed people will spend good money
on an Accountant to help them show as little
income as possible through deductions &
different accounting methods. This helps greatly
when it’s time to pay taxes. This hurts when
it’s time to go for a loan.
If you are showing a very low income, telling
the lender “I really make much more than that,
but it’s not on the tax returns” won’t help.
Lenders take the approach if it’s not on the tax
return, it didn’t happen. After all, how are
they supposed to get a comfort level that you
really did make more, and how much? So they only
consider what the return shows. They may add the
annual figures you have listed for depreciation
and amortization back to income, that’s about
it.
About the only thing you can do to combat this
disadvantage is to keep your credit strong with
a high credit score. The higher your credit
score, the more likely lenders will put less
weight on your returns. That is not a cure all,
but lenders will get a lot more motivated and
have more programs and workaround solutions
available if you have a 725 credit score with
low income reflected on your Tax Returns as
opposed to a 625 credit score with low income
reflected on your Tax Returns. If you know that
in a year or two your company will need to
obtain loans, discuss this with your accountant.
This is an important reason for showing income
on your Tax Returns. Consider how much you will
borrow, and how much the monthly payments will
be for. Based on that, use your accountant’s
advice on how much you should show in annual
income to show a lender that you can meet all
your monthly obligations plus the additional
monthly obligation of the loan they are
considering. This is extra work and hassle, but
if the loan you need down the line is important,
do it.
If you are a Corporation, it is likely that your
returns show close to zero net income. This is
what is supposed to happen, as it is common for
corporations not to end up reflecting an income.
Ironically, many lenders ask for the corporate
returns and decline requests due to
“insufficient cash flow”. In such a case, you
should provide your personal tax returns also,
since they will show income and strengthen your
loan request
Personal Financial Statements
Lenders may
request for you to complete a Personal Financial
Statement, especially for larger loan requests.
A Personal Financial Statement, in addition to
tax returns and income verification, are among
the most common ways for lenders to quickly take
a look at your financial situation.
The primary things lenders look for on Personal
Financial Statements are:
1) What is your liquidity? Liquidity
means what you list for cash on hand, in
checking & savings accounts, money market
accounts, 401K retirement plans, Certificates of
Deposit, listed Stocks (Listed means listed on
the New York Stock Exchange or American Stock
Exchange as opposed to stock issued by a non
public company not listed on one of the above
exchanges.
2) New Worth This is your total assets
less your total liabilities. What lenders
commonly look for is things most people list as
personal property such as furniture, artwork,
furnishings, collectables, jewelry, household
items, as well as overvalued Real Estate, and
deduct these from the total of your assets. The
lenders believe should you default on a loan,
they really cannot and have no interest in
repossessing these items and trying to sell them
for pennies on the dollar, so the completely
deduct them from your asset value.
Most people over-value their real estate
holdings, both personal and commercial. Lenders
know this, will assess the value you listed and
quickly discount it by 10% to 20%, or more,
depending on what value you list for your home.
Depending on what you are applying for, they
will then make an assessment of how you look
financially, and based on the product and loan
criteria, weigh your liquidity and Net worth
into their decision.
Although a good New Worth is important, your
liquidity is most important. Lenders see this as
a secondary source of repayment. If you run into
a problem financially, having a money market
account or savings account will allow you to
easily make a payment on a loan as opposed to
simply not being able to make that payment. If
you do not have cash in an account, it will be
much harder for you to come up with a payment if
you run into a problem.
Income verification & Tax Returns
A lender may request verification of your
income via a paystub or a tax return. If you are
employed by someone, providing a paystub is easy
and satisfies the request.
If you earn part of your income in commissions
or bonuses, provide your most recent Tax Return,
since the total income will be higher, making it
more likely you will be approved. If your
previous year has a higher income, provide the
last 2 years returns because the average will be
higher. The only exception to this is if the
most recent year is substantially lower than the
previous year. If that is the case, you don’t
want to provide the previous year because it
will look like your income is going down!
|